Mass Effect Series Game Rankings

Didn’t make it in time for N7 Day, but The Mass Effect series stands as one of the most iconic franchises in the realm of action RPGs. It’s also one of my favorite series of all time, with multiple games as some of my top favorites. The journey across galaxies, the compelling narrative, and the intricate characters have left an indelible mark on myself and many other gamers. The series has seen its share of highs and lows within the 4 games in the series. This isn’t my personal ranking, but rather what I believe to be a consensus for gamers overall. So here is the ranking from worst to best delving into the nuances of what makes each title unique and where they falter.

4. Mass Effect Andromeda (2017)

A New Galaxy, New Ideas, and Mixed Execution

Mass Effect: Andromeda was an attempt to take the series in a new direction. The game went away from the familiar faces and locations of the Milky Way we knew and loved. Unfortunately, it didn’t live up to the legacy of the original trilogy in most people’s eyes. The game is set in the Andromeda galaxy, with the player taking on the role of Pathfinder Ryder. This new setting offered the potential for fresh storytelling and exploration, but it struggled to capture the same sense of wonder. Andromeda leans heavily into open-world design, with expansive planets to explore. The Nomad vehicle replaces the Mako, offering smoother traversal. However, the open-world elements can feel repetitive, with many fetch quests and filler content.

At launch, Andromeda was plagued by numerous bugs and animation issues, which overshadowed much of the game’s content. I can’t remember how many times I saw memes regarding the character’s facial animations. Although many of these problems were patched, the damage to its reputation was significant. Despite its flaws, Andromeda has the best combat mechanics in the series. The addition of jump jets, a more fluid cover system, and dynamic ability customization make encounters exciting and fast-paced. The new characters, while serviceable, lack the depth and charisma of the original trilogy’s cast. The game attempts to create memorable relationships, but they often fall flat compared to the bonds formed with Shepard’s crew.

Why It’s Ranked Last

Mass Effect: Andromeda aimed high but suffered from execution issues. Its technical problems, uneven writing, and lack of a strong narrative focus made it a disappointment for many fans. However, its combat system and some aspects of exploration show flashes of the series’ former glory.

3. Mass Effect 3 (2012)

An Epic Conclusion with a Polarizing Ending

Mass Effect 3 had the challenging task of concluding one of gaming’s most beloved trilogies. It succeeds in many aspects but falters in others, especially with its controversial ending. The stakes are higher than ever, with the full-scale invasion of the Reapers threatening the galaxy. The game excels at delivering emotional moments, particularly with characters like Mordin Solus, Tali’Zorah, and Garrus Vakarian. The final confrontations with longstanding enemies and allies provide closure for many arcs. The combat system in Mass Effect 3 is the most polished of the trilogy. It features faster movement, better cover mechanics, and a broader range of abilities and weapons.

The addition of the Omni-Blade and melee combat options adds variety. The co-op multiplayer mode, although initially met with skepticism, became a beloved feature. It ties into the main game’s war assets system, providing a fun diversion with a meaningful impact on the single-player experience. The biggest point of contention for Mass Effect 3 is its ending. Many fans felt that the final choices did not adequately reflect the decisions made throughout the trilogy. BioWare’s release of the Extended Cut DLC attempted to address some of these issues, but the damage was already done for many players. We still hear to this day about people’s issues with the ending.

Why It’s Ranked Here

While Mass Effect 3 has some of the series’ best moments, the divisive ending and a slightly more linear structure prevent it from surpassing its predecessors. However, it remains a strong, emotional conclusion to an epic saga.

2. Mass Effect (2007)

A Groundbreaking Beginning: The Game That Started It All

The original Mass Effect was a revolutionary game that laid the foundation for the series. It introduced players to Commander Shepard, the Normandy, and the vast, interconnected galaxy filled with diverse alien species. It’s also my personal favorite in the series and I rank it number one. Mass Effect set a high bar for storytelling in video games. The main plot, revolving around the rogue Spectre Saren and the looming threat of the Reapers, is compelling and filled with twists. I also believe Saren is the best villain in the series. The game’s exploration of philosophical themes like synthetic vs. organic life and the nature of control sets it apart.

This is the most RPG-heavy game in the series, with extensive dialogue trees, detailed skill customization, and a strong emphasis on player choices. The Paragon/Renegade morality system introduced a new level of consequence-driven gameplay. Mass Effect features a semi-open world with a focus on planetary exploration via the Mako. While the Mako sections received mixed reviews due to clunky controls, they added a sense of scale to the galaxy. The combat in Mass Effect is its weakest aspect, feeling clunky and imprecise. The game’s reliance on inventory management can also be cumbersome, but it fits with the RPG roots.

Why It Ranks High

Despite its gameplay flaws, to people, Mass Effect offers one of the most immersive experiences in the series. Its pioneering narrative structure and world-building created a universe that players were eager to explore.

1. Mass Effect 2 (2010)

The Best of the Series: A Masterclass in Narrative and Character Development

Mass Effect 2 is often hailed as the pinnacle of the series by the majority, and for good reason. This sequel took the best elements of the original game and polished them to near perfection. Mass Effect 2 is renowned for its intense, character-driven storytelling. It introduces the Suicide Mission, a daring final act where every decision made throughout the game can result in the life or death of your crew. This gives weight to every interaction and mission. The cast in Mass Effect 2 is arguably the strongest in the series. The loyalty missions, which delve into each character’s backstory, are a highlight.

From the conflicted Miranda Lawson to the charming Garrus Vakarian, the game gives you memorable allies whose arcs are intertwined with the main story. BioWare refined the combat system, making it more responsive and action-oriented. The addition of heavy weapons, streamlined abilities, and improved cover mechanics make the gameplay feel fluid and engaging. There is a darker tone to the game and the exploration of Cerberus’ morally ambiguous role provides a compelling backdrop. There is a plethora of different environments, from the bustling Omega station to the derelict Collector ship, which keeps the setting fresh.

Why It’s The Best

In people’s opinions, Mass Effect 2 strikes the perfect balance between storytelling, character development, and gameplay improvements. It is the emotional core of the trilogy and offers the most consistent experience from start to finish.

Final Thoughts – A Transformative Series

The Mass Effect series has left an indelible impact on gaming as a whole. Many people, including myself, believe that each title offers something unique:

• Mass Effect 2: The perfect blend of narrative, character development, and refined gameplay.
• Mass Effect: A groundbreaking start, rich in world-building and RPG elements.
• Mass Effect 3: A powerful, emotional conclusion marred by its divisive ending.
• Mass Effect: Andromeda: A flawed but ambitious attempt to take the series in a new direction.

While fans continue to debate the merits of each game to this day, there was even a roundtable discussion on the Iron Lords Podcast channel about these games as you can see above. The Mass Effect series remains a shining example of storytelling in video games. Whether you’re experiencing it for the first time or revisiting old favorites, the journey across the stars with Commander Shepard and their crew is hard to forget. It has left a lasting impact on gamers around the world! Let me know what you think!